ButtSharpies

still tight despite my daily stretching :(

ButtSharpies

35

Can fit 6 in on my first try. After 6 it was very tight but Im proud of my efforts

ButtSharpies

224

Lucky 13

ButtSharpies

324

gave it a shot, gonna need to buy a pack

ButtSharpies

28

Second time. Was hoping to fit 8 in but could only get 7 and even that hurt. Think I need to practice daily. My apologies for the bad pic. It was hard to take a good one today.

ButtSharpies

117

Dared by a friend, I hope we make his day. HeilHipster

ButtSharpies

16

My (f)irst post here, be gentle

ButtSharpies

357

made it to 4! need some help making it to 5, im already so tight!

ButtSharpies

227

Green team

ButtSharpies

158

Butt Sharpie Challenge Day 20! Twenty! oof, never thought I would make it this far, def feeling FULL!

ButtSharpies

282

I got TWO!

ButtSharpies

21

How many should I fill this slut with

ButtSharpies

17

Ok so I got some larger ones to try as well

ButtSharpies

108

just found a new challenge

ButtSharpies

46

Should I try for more or nah?

ButtSharpies

188

There are markers in my butt

ButtSharpies

198

6 is a good start

ButtSharpies

75

Work from home? My holes can be used for multiple purposes. Easy under desk storage design. [F]

ButtSharpies

13

Sharpie anyone?

ButtSharpies

67

One sharpie for this tight ass

ButtSharpies

161

One in! [FtM]

ButtSharpies

126

Where mommy keeps her office supplies..

ButtSharpies

128

How do you like my first try :>?

ButtSharpies

63

No better butt plug than sharpies (NSFW)

ButtSharpies

228

Mischievously stole some sharpies for a.project, hope they arent missed

ButtSharpies

22

Here's 11! More to come!

ButtSharpies

57

first time

ButtSharpies

64

My teenage asshole is that tight that it just pushes the sharpie right out!

ButtSharpies

36

Beat my personal best of thirteen, but only by one!

ButtSharpies

85

its my First post here please be genttle

ButtSharpies

14

First time

ButtSharpies

123

Just a first try

ButtSharpies

22

Do you still remember me?

ButtSharpies

191

FOUR Im scared to try more

ButtSharpies

129

Butt Sharpie Challenge Day 14! Two weeks!!! Think I can make it to three?

ButtSharpies

281

My 1st post here

ButtSharpies

562

What should mommy shove in her ass next?!

ButtSharpies

164

I found your missing pen

ButtSharpies

68

Butt Sharpies Day 6! You all were so nice on my catch-up post I guess I'll keep sharing!

ButtSharpies

188

20 for my first try. how'd I do? [NB]

ButtSharpies

178

Can anyone help me train my tight little bussy?

ButtSharpies

10

11 on the first try (OC)

ButtSharpies

96

Butt Sharpie Challenge Day 8! Onto week 2, thanks everyone for all the support this far, I feel like we're just getting started ;-)

ButtSharpies

31

What should I shove in my ass next?!

ButtSharpies

64

Couldnt get the 5th to stay in my wifes tight ass

ButtSharpies

202

Butt Sharpie Challenge Day 11! Oh man, think I can make it to two weeks?

ButtSharpies

265

Always love classic butt sharpies - X-post from r/EbonyAssholes

ButtSharpies

123

got to 9, quite the stretch!!

ButtSharpies

13

Not bad for my first try with sharpies

ButtSharpies

242

Not quite sharpies, but I still fart them out of my tight pink teen asshole

ButtSharpies

422

Love being double stuffed

ButtSharpies

56

Started with one.. now Im addicted

ButtSharpies

167

Nice!

ButtSharpies

290

What should mommy shove in her ass next?!

ButtSharpies

238

Success! Had to do a little improvisation with the colors, but here is it. Taste the rainbow.

ButtSharpies

270

Just one for now...

ButtSharpies

25

Only 5 but this was just a warm up for her.

ButtSharpies

70

3 for now but I bought the 10 pack so stay tuned

ButtSharpies

46

Taste the rainbow!

ButtSharpies

45

Didnt have sharpies but pencils do the trick!

ButtSharpies

12